ACNE
VULGARIS AND ACNEIFORM ERUPTIONS
Acne
vulgaris is the most commonly treated skin condition . Prompt and appropriate
treatment of acne is essential. Because acne primarily occurs during
adolescence, when self-image is being formed, even a mild case can have a
profound effect on psychosocial development and performance in school. Moderate
to severe acne, with its attendant scarring, can cause significant disfigurement
that persists throughout life and affects career choice and employability. In
the past 30 years, however, considerable understanding of the pathogenesis of
acne has been achieved, leading to the development of rational, effective, and
safe treatments.
Epidemiology
Acne
affects persons of all ages, but adolescents and young adults are the most
frequently affected. Acne may occur in children as young as eight years and
often occurs in those 10 to 12 years of age. Contrary to popular expectation,
acne does not always resolve by the end of the teenage years. In fact, it may
persist into the 40s, and in women, its onset may not occur until the mid-20s.
Acne occurs in boys more frequently than in girls.
Anatomy
Acne
is a disease of the pilosebaceous unit. Each pilosebaceous unit consists of a
hair follicle and a sebaceous gland that drains directly into the hair follicle.
To explain the pathogenesis of acne to patients and to dispel the many myths
about the disease, the physician must have a basic understanding of the anatomy
and physiology of the pilosebaceous unit.
types of pilosebaceous units
Human
facial skin has three functional and morphological varieties of pilosebaceous
units-vellus follicles, terminal follicles, and sebaceous follicles . The vellus
hair grows from the orifice of an inconspicuous but otherwise completely
developed follicle. Compared with the size of the follicle, the sebaceous gland
is large. In contrast, the terminal follicle produces a fully developed hair,
such as a beard hair. This hair is thick and stiff and has a diameter almost the
size of that of the follicle. Terminal follicles are larger than vellus
follicles, but the larger number of vellus follicles on the face contributes
significantly to the production of surface lipids.
The sebaceous follicle is huge compared with its barely perceptible hair, which
may not even protrude from the follicular opening. The sebaceous gland is also
large and is multilobulated. The coincidence of a large follicle, a small and
insignificant hair, and a well-developed sebaceous gland makes an ideal setting
for the development of an acne lesion because debris can easily accumulate to
produce comedones. The accumulation of debris that can occur in sebaceous
follicles does not occur in terminal follicles, at least in part because of the
mechanical properties and size of the hairs in the terminal follicles. Indeed,
acne is primarily a disease of sebaceous follicles. The distribution of
sebaceous follicles on the face, earlobes, neck, shoulders, and V-shaped areas
of the upper central chest and back corresponds to that of acne.
anatomy of the hair follicle
The
hair follicle is an epidermal tubular sac in the dermis. It is completely lined
with stratified epithelium that is contiguous with the surface, or
interfollicular, epithelium. The various regions of the hair follicle have both
structural and functional significance.
The
lower part of the follicle, or inferior segment, extends from the deepest part
of the hair follicle to the insertion point of the arrector pili muscle. The
inferior segment contains the hair bulb and the hair matrix, which is the
germinative epitheli um that gives rise to the hair shaft. This part of the hair
follicle is present only in follicles with growing (anagen) hairs and is absent
in follicles with resting (telogen) hairs.
The
middle part of the follicle, or isthmus, extends from the insertion point of the
arrector pili muscle to the opening of the sebaceous gland. Its upper extent is
also defined by the disintegration of the inner root sheath, which functions as
a mold for the forming hair.
The
upper part of the follicle, or infundibulum, is divided into two regions. The
acroinfundibulum contains epithelium with properties like those of surface
epidermis. The infrainfundibulum, which lines most of the length of this segment
of the hair follicle, differs morphologically and functionally from the
acroinfundibulum and is where the pathognomonic microcomedo of acne develops.
This stratified epithelium gives rise to fully differentiated cornified cells
that normally are shed into the hair follicle canal and carried to the surface
by the flow of sebum. Abnormalities of the epidermis of the follicular
infrainfundibulum result in increased production and decreased shedding of these
cornified cells and are currently considered the primary cause of acne.
anatomy and physiology of the sebaceous gland
The
function of the sebaceous gland is to secrete sebum, a complex mixture of
lipids. The sebaceous gland, like all of the epidermal appendages, arises from
primordial cells contained in the fetal epidermis. At about eight weeks of
gestation, focal areas of thickening of the primitive epidermis form above foci
of mesenchymal cells in the dermis. Downward growth of epidermal cells results
in the formation of the primordial hair follicles. The sebaceous gland arises
from a bulge in the epithelium of the hair follicle above the level of the
insertion of the arrector pili muscle. The rapid development of this structure
in the fetus is driven by maternal androgenic hormones.
The
gland is fully functional well before birth. This hypothesis is supported by the
presence of the vernix caseosa, a cheesy substance composed of sebum and
adherent cornified cells, on the skin of newborns and by the occurrence of
neonatal acne, a fine papulopustular eruption on the faces of newborns. The
sebaceous glands regress by three to six months of age and remain small and
minimally active until early puberty; at that time, androgenic hormones
stimulate the glands to enlarge, differentiate, and secrete sebum.
Androgenic
hormones play the dominant role in regulating sebaceous gland activity.
Circulating androgens arising from both the gonads and the adrenal glands are
complemented by the peripheral conversion of testosterone to dihydrotestosterone
in the sebaceous gland. The source redundancy and peripheral conversion of
androgenic hormones may partly explain why consistent elevations of serum
androgens are not observed in patients with acne .
composition of sebum
Sebum
consists principally of triglycerides, wax esters, and squalene. The composition
of sebum differs from that of epidermal surface lipids in that some of the
triglycerides in sebum have been hydrolyzed to free fatty acids. It was once
thought that free fatty acids play a central role in the pathogenesis of acne;
this hypothesis was supported by considerable circumstantial evidence. However,
topical application of potent inhibitors of bacterial lipases, which rapidly
inhibit the formation of free fatty acids, has since been shown to alter neither
the sebum secretion rate nor the number of lesions. It is now thought that free
fatty acids play a minimal role in the pathogenesis of acne.
Pathogenesis of Acne
microcomedo formation
The
earliest lesion of acne is the microcomedo. It is clinically inapparent but is
easily seen under the microscope as a concretion of keratinocytes, sebum, and
colonies of bacteria in the follicular infundibulum. The microcomedo forms as a
result of accelerated proliferation of keratinocytes in the follicular
infundibulum and increased adherence of differentiated cornified cells.
Continued aggregation of cornified cells leads to widening of the follicular
infundibulum and production of a closed comedo. The hyperkeratosis may then
extend to and dilate the follicular opening, forming an open comedo that permits
the discharge of sebum and cornified cells; alternatively, the follicular wall
ruptures, leading to the appearance of inflammatory papules and pustules.
role of androgens
Androgens
are essential in the pathogenesis of acne. Many studies have reported endocrine
abnormalities in patients with acne, but only a small proportion of women with
acne exhibit signs of excessive androgen production, such as male pattern
alopecia and hirsutism, or symptoms of significant menstrual dysfunction. In
patients with mild acne, circulating levels of androgens are usually normal and
peripheral conversion is increased, whereas in patients with severe acne,
circulating levels of androgens are also elevated.
role of seborrhea
Although
the severity of acne correlates with the rate of sebum production, acne is
primarily a disease of the follicular infundibulum. How sebum excretion is
related to abnormalities of the follicular infundibulum is unclear.
role of microbial colonization
The
organisms that colonize sebum-rich skin are Propionibacterium acnes, Micrococcus
and Staphylococcus species, aerobic coryneform bacteria, and species of
the yeast genus Malassezia (formerly called Pityrosporum).
However, the importance of these organisms in the pathogenesis of acne vulgaris,
once dogma, is now debated.
Several
observations support the hypothesis that Propionibacterium species play
an important role in the pathogenesis of acne. Antibiotics have been
successfully used for decades to treat acne. In addition, increased skin
colonization occurs at puberty and is associated with increased sebum production
and with the development of acne. Finally, the emergence of antibiotic-resistant
strains of Propionibacterium is associated with clinical exacerbation of
disease.
Other
observations support the hypothesis that microbial colonization plays little or
no role in the pathogenesis of acne. Although the density of the microbial flora
in patients with acne differs significantly from that in patients with normal
skin, the severity of acne is not correlated with the number of organisms. In
addition, comedonal acne and inflammatory acne occur in patients with follicles
from which viable organisms cannot be recovered; conversely, Propionibacterium
species can be found in the follicles of both normal patients and those with
acne. Proponents of this hypothesis also point out that the well-documented
efficacy of antibiotics in the management of acne may be caused by the
anti-inflammatory properties of these drugs and their ability to inhibit protein
synthesis and extracellular enzymes, not their antimicrobial activity.
Clinical Features
Acne
occurs on the skin of the face, upper back, and upper chest, a distribution that
corresponds to the distribution of sebaceous follicles. Occasionally, lesions
may be more widespread. Acne is frequently but not always associated with
seborrhea, or excessive oiliness of the skin. The lesions are polymorphic,
consisting of open and closed comedones, erythematous papules, pustules,
nodules, cysts, and scars of various morphological types.
The
diagnostic clinical lesion, the comedo, contains keratinized cells, sebum, and
some bacteria. Comedones may be present in open or closed follicles , but
inflammatory lesions tend to develop around closed comedones.
The
open comedo, or blackhead, is the most recognizable morphological sign of acne,
but its presence is not required for the diagnosis. Open comedones are visible
concretions that are 0.5 to 2.0 mm in diameter. They take several weeks to
develop. It was once thought that their black color was caused by oxidized fatty
acids, but studies have convincingly demonstrated that it is caused by the
presence of melanin. When the comedo is removed by the application of steady,
gentle pressure, it can be seen to be a greasy, wormlike excrescence with a
gray-white color.
Closed
comedones are probably much more common than open comedones in patients with
acne but are much more difficult to detect on clinical examination. The closed
comedo is a barely palpable whitish papule that is 0.1 to 2.0 mm in diameter and
that lies just below the surface of the skin. The follicular orifice may be
hardly visible. If these lesions do not become inflamed, they resolve
spontaneously in a few weeks to a few months.
The
inflammatory lesions of acne begin as follicular papules that may develop into
pustules or as nodules that may evolve into cysts . The papules are reddish and
vary in size and consistency. Papules often appear to arise on clinically normal
skin, but in almost all cases, a closed comedo was previously present. The
lesions are an average of about 4 mm in diameter. If papules do not evolve into
pustules, they resolve, leaving an erythematous macule and, ultimately, normal
skin or an abnormally pigmented macule.
Pustules
may be tender and surmount an erythematous papule or macule. Superficial
pustules usually run their course and dry up in less than a week. Deep pustules
are more common in patients with more severe cases of acne. These lesions are
almost always tender and take two to six weeks to resolve.
As
papules and pustules resolve, they may leave areas of hyperpigmentation and
hypopigmentation that are of special cosmetic significance in dark-skinned
patients. Areas of hyperpigmentation may require more than a year to resolve.
Although scarring is usually associated with deeper nodular and cystic lesions,
scarring may also be a sequela of less inflammatory, more superficial papules
and pustules.
Nodules
are very deep seated lesions that are often 1 cm or larger in diameter and that
vary in consistency from firm to fluctuant. Occasionally, several lesions appear
to coalesce; these lesions are often painful. Cysts, which are fairly uncommon,
may reach a size of several centimeters in diameter. These lesions may coalesce
and form boggy sinuses with multiple openings to the surface; this condition is
called acne conglobata . The lesions of acne conglobata resolve with noticeable
scarring.
Because
scarring is associated with both the superficial and the deep inflammatory
lesions of acne, early and aggressive medical intervention should be instituted
for patients with these lesions. Fortunately, acne scars undergo physiologic
remodeling for months and years after the acne has become quiescent. This fact
should be stressed to patients who are concerned about the cosmetic appearance
of their scars. Scars may be either hypertrophic and associated with increased
amounts of collagen or atrophic and associated with some tissue loss. Each type
of scar presents unique therapeutic challenges.
Atrophic
scars are characterized as so-called ice-pick scars, fibrotic scars, or
elastolytic scars. Ice-pick scars usually occur on the cheeks and forehead. The
lesions are small and irregular, jagged, or polygonal and have very sharp, steep
sides. Some have a distinctive fibrotic component that does not allow the scar
to be stretched. Fibrotic scars are depressed craters that have smoother borders
merging into normal skin and shallower sides; they are generally larger than
ice-pick scars. Small elastolytic scars occur in a follicular distribution, but
larger elastolytic scars are associated with such destruction of the dermis that
a follicular origin is not apparent. The epidermis has a thin cigarette-paper
appearance, and the dermis has a distinctive softness on palpation, as if it
were absent. Occasionally, the dermis bulges outward under a thin, atrophic
epidermis; this pattern of scarring occurs because of loss of integrity of the
elastin network in the dermis.
Diagnosis
basic clinical presentations
The
lesions of acne vulgaris fall into three basic clinical patterns-comedonal,
papulopustular, and nodulocystic. Therapy is directed by the type and severity
of the lesions.
In
comedonal acne, the predominant lesions are open and closed comedones. A few
small inflammatory papules and pustules may be present.
When
papules and pustules are the predominant lesions, however, larger numbers of P.
acnes organisms in the skin lesions and evidence of follicular wall
degeneration and rupture are present. Papulopustular acne leads to scarring and
requires prompt and aggressive intervention.
Nodulocystic
acne comprises a broad spectrum of clinical presentations. It includes patients
with a few nodules and cysts on the face; those with widespread nodules and
cysts on the face, chest, and back; those with pyoderma faciale (the presence of
eruptive, suppurating lesions on the face, a condition that usually occurs in
women); those with acne conglobata and
those with acne fulminans .
variants
The
disease name acne is subjected to more modifiers than are nearly all of the
other disease names in medicine. All of the variants of acne are characterized
by comedones, papules and pustules, or inflammatory nodules and cysts , but they
clearly fall outside the spectrum of acne vulgaris; one variant, hidradenitis
suppurativa, is probably not even very closely related to acne vulgaris. Each
variant has its own clinical features and recommended treatment .
Differential Diagnosis
milia
Milia,
the tiny inclusion cysts that arise when vellus follicles are obstructed, may
erupt in substantial numbers on the forehead and chest, mimicking acne. They
differ from epidermal inclusion cysts only in size. They frequently occur around
the eyes and are distinguished from closed comedones by the absence of a visible
follicular ostium. Treatment consists of opening the cysts and expressing the
contents.
malassezia folliculitis
This
eruption, which usually occurs on the trunk, appears as inflammatory papules but
is not unequivocally associated with hair follicles. Some areas of vague
erythema may be marked by regularly spaced, clearly follicular papules. When pus
is expressed from a suppurating lesion, Gram's stain reveals the characteristic
gram-positive budding yeast. Treatment consists of shampooing with topical
selenium sulfide, applying topical imidazole antifungal drugs, or taking oral
ketoconazole.
perioral dermatitis
Perioral
dermatitis is a monomorphous, acnelike eruption that occurs on the lower part of
the face and that typically occurs in women. It is often associated with the use
of fluorinated topical steroids on that part of the body. A narrow zone adjacent
to the vermilion is often spared. Treatment consists of discontinuance of the
fluorinated topical steroid (usually by tapering it and eventually substituting
a lower-potency nonfluorinated topical steroid for it) and administration of
topical or oral tetracycline or topical metronidazole.
rosacea
Rosacea
consists of inflammatory papules and pustules, telangiectasia or central facial
flushing, and sebaceous gland hyperplasia. Although the eruption usually occurs
in persons older than 30 years, differentiating it from acne vulgaris by other
characteristics may be very difficult. Rhinophyma, consisting of profound
hyperplasia of the sebaceous glands on the nose and chronic lymphedema caused by
destruction of the facial lymphatics by inflammation in the deep dermis, may
occur. The flushing and telangiectasia of rosacea are exacerbated by consumption
of hot liquids, such as coffee, or of alcohol. Treatment consists of removal of
exacerbating factors and the administration of topical or oral tetracycline,
topical hydrocortisone, or topical metronidazole.
Approach to the Patient with Acne
In
eliciting the history, the physician should ask about the patient's age at onset
of acne and the history of disease progression; whether seasonal variation or
aggravation by stress occurs; the patient's occupation and exposure to foreign
substances; the patient's history of skin disease, especially that of dry skin
or atopic dermatitis; the patient's propensity to scar; and the patient's
general health, especially his or her endocrine, hepatic, and renal function.
Women should be asked about their cosmetic use, premenstrual flares, pregnancy
status and menstrual history, symptoms of virilization, previous endocrine
evaluations, and use of oral contraceptive agents and their effect on acne. The
physician should obtain a detailed list of the over-the-counter and prescription
topical and systemic agents that the patient is taking for acne and other
medical problems and should pay special attention to potential drug
interactions. Understanding the details of previous treatments and their
successes and failures helps the physician judge the potential success of future
therapies and assess the patient's frustration with efforts to control the
condition.
On
physical examination, the physician should make note of the types of current
lesions (open or closed comedones, papules, pustules, nodules, or cysts), types
of residual lesions (including postinflammatory hyperpigmentation or
hypopigmentation), and types of scars. An unusual distribution of lesions should
lead the physician to search for extrinsic causal factors. For example, acne on
only the left side of the neck ("fiddler's neck") may occur in
violinists; that on only the forehead and chin may occur in football players.
Chloracne may occur behind the ears as a result of exposure to chlorinated
hydrocarbon compounds such as tetrachlorodibenzodioxin, and pomade acne may
occur where the hair comes in contact with facial skin. Acne mechanica, caused
by various orthopedic or prosthetic appliances or football shoulder pads, should
be suspected when eruptions occur on the back and shoulders but nowhere else or
on amputation stumps.
Excessive
muscularity may suggest that the patient is surreptitiously using anabolic
steroids; the presence of monomorphous pustules may suggest the use of lithium
carbonate, the use of corticosteroids, or gram-negative folliculitis. In women,
the presence of nodulocystic acne should trigger an examination for other signs
of virilization; that of ulcerations and excoriations, an examination for
excoriated acne; and excessive use of layered cosmetics, an examination for acne
cosmetica. The physician should be alert to the presence of xerosis (dry skin),
atopic dermatitis, eczema, or photosensitivity because the presence of these
conditions may preclude the use of some topical treatments.
Treatment
overall strategy
Treatment
of acne can be directed at achieving any of four major goals: removal of the
existing comedones and prevention of new ones, reduction of the amount of sebum
synthesized by the sebaceous glands, reduction of the numbers of P. acnes
organisms, and reduction of the inflammatory response to follicular rupture,
thereby reducing or preventing scarring. Therapeutic agents that achieve one or
more of these four goals may be used singly or in combination as appropriate for
the clinical situation.
Patients
should be instructed to routinely cleanse the skin with mild soap and water
before applying topical agents. Patients should also be told that a response to
treatment, however aggressive, will not occur immediately. It is incumbent on
the physician to know and anticipate some of the problems associated with acne
treatment and when results can be expected so that the patient can be
appropriately counseled. Acne will be many patients' first experience with a
chronic medical problem; the physician must take special care to communicate
clearly and set realistic goals to achieve good compliance and a favorable
outcome. The many myths about acne should be addressed and dispelled .
The
management of a patient with acne vulgaris depends on the numbers, kinds, and
distribution of lesions present (i.e., a correct assessment of the type of acne
vulgaris an assessment of the
patient's likely sensitivity to irritation; and an assessment of the patient's
propensity to scar. A so-called cookbook approach to acne management will not
succeed; sound clinical judgment is required. Although topical and systemic
treatments may be used alone or in combination, combination therapy provides
distinct advantages except in very mild or very severe cases.
topical treatment
The
three basic topical treatments used in patients with acne vulgaris are
retinoids, benzoyl peroxide, and antibiotics. Each has benefits for selected
patients and problems associated with its use.
Tretinoin (Vitamin A Acid)
Mechanism
of action Tretinoin is comedolytic. It decreases the
cohesiveness of follicular epithelial cells and increases the mitotic rate and
turnover of follicular epithelium, effects that contribute to the extrusion of
comedones. Tretinoin treatment also prevents new comedo formation and thereby
indirectly prevents the evolution of more inflammatory and potentially scarring
lesions. Although the thinning of the cornified cell layer of the
interfollicular epithelium effected by tretinoin renders the epidermis more
susceptible to irritation, it also allows better penetration of adjunctive
topical agents such as benzoyl peroxide (see below).
Formulations
Tretinoin is available in a gel base in concentrations of 0.01 percent and 0.025
percent; in a cream base (hydrophilic cream) in concentrations of 0.1 percent,
0.05 percent, and 0.025 percent; and in solution (0.05 percent). The solution is
more drying than the gels, and the gels are more drying than the creams.
Indications
Tretinoin is used as monotherapy for comedonal acne; if tolerated, it can be
used in conjunction with other modalities for other clinical forms of acne.
Benzoyl
Peroxide
Mechanism
of action Benzoyl peroxide is an antibac terial agent that
decreases the number of P. acnes organisms by about 2.0 log10
in 48 hours. Benzoyl peroxide also
may reduce the number of comedones and have a slight direct anti-inflammatory
effect.
Formulations
Benzoyl peroxide is available in numerous over-the-counter and prescription
formulations. The acetone- or alcohol-based formulations are more irritating and
drying but possibly more effective than the water-based formulations. It is
commonly available in strengths of 2.5 percent, 5.0 percent, and 10.0 percent,
but there is little evidence to support a therapeutically important
dose-response relation at these concentrations. Most practitioners recommend
beginning with a lower concentration of a water-based formulation to prevent the
potentially severe skin irritation and peeling induced by the higher
concentrations.
Indications
Benzoyl peroxide is used as monotherapy for mild to moderate inflammatory acne,
but synergistic effects are obtained when it is used in conjunction with topical
tretinoin and possibly when it is used in conjunction with topical or oral
antibiotics.
Topical Antibiotics
Mechanism
of action Topical antibiotics suppress the growth of P. acnes
and thereby decrease the likelihood of follicular rupture and the intensity of
the subsequent inflammatory response.
Formulations
Topical preparations of tetracycline, meclocycline, erythromycin, clindamycin,
and a combination of erythromycin and benzoyl peroxide are available. All of
these preparations use an alcohol-containing vehicle and thus tend to be drying
and irritating. Although topical tetracycline administered twice daily is as
effective as oral tetracycline, 250 mg, administered twice daily, few comparison
studies have been performed and a clear dose-response relation has not been
established.
Indications
Topical antibiotics are used as monotherapy for mild to moderate inflammatory
acne, but the best results are obtained when a topical antibiotic is combined
with other topical treatments such as tretinoin.
systemic treatment
Oral Antibiotic Treatment
Mechanism
of action Treatment with oral antibiotics reduces the number of P.
acnes organisms but decreases neither the rate of sebum secretion nor the
number of comedones. Oral antibiotics have well-documented nonantimicrobial
properties that have been thought to play a role in the management of acne; the
importance of these properties remains to be defined.
Therapeutic
options and dosing Tetracycline (250 to 500 mg twice daily) is
commonly prescribed. It is lipophilic and therefore becomes concentrated in
sebum, and it has few side effects. Tetracycline-resistant strains of P.
acnes do not emerge even after years of use. Erythromycin (250 to 500 mg
twice daily) is equally effective, but gastrointestinal side effects often limit
the use of this drug. The second-generation tetracyclines minocycline and
doxycycline (50 to 100 mg daily or twice daily) offer certain advantages, such
as being better absorbed with food and having a greater bioavailability that
permits once-daily dosing. Laboratory monitoring is not cost-effective even when
long periods of oral antibiotic therapy are anticipated.
Indications
Systemic antibiotics are used as therapy for moderate to severe inflammatory
acne or for inflammatory acne that does not respond to other measures.
Alternative Antibiotic Regimens
Short
courses of trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole (80 mg of trimethoprim and 400 mg of
sulfamethoxazole) or an oral cephalosporin are occasionally beneficial in the
short-term management of patients who have acne that is unresponsive to
conventional antibiotic treatment. Most of these patients are eventually given
isotretinoin .
adjunctive measures
Removal of Open and Closed Comedones
Because
closed comedones are the precursors of the inflammatory acne lesions that cause
scarring, as many as possible should be removed mechanically. Closed comedones
should be opened with an 18- to 20-gauge needle. The opening of a comedo
extractor should be placed over the open or just-opened comedo. Direct uniform
pressure should then be applied over the opening of the follicle until the
comedo is extruded.
Intralesional Corticosteroid Injection
Suppurating
acne lesions are disfiguring and often quite painful. Intralesional
corticosteroid injections promptly relieve pain and suppress the inflammatory
reaction. The skin should be cleansed with an alcohol swab. Triamcinolone
diacetate (10 mg/ml for intralesional use) should be diluted with saline or
lidocaine to 3 to 5 mg/ml and mixed thoroughly before it is injected. The
injection should be given through the thinnest portion of the top of and
directly into the suppurating lesion. Only 0.05 to 0.2 ml of the suspension, or
just enough to make the overlying skin blanch because of distention, should be
injected into each inflammatory lesion.
treatment of the unresponsive patient
Success
in treating patients with acne does not occur automatically; the sympathy and
interest of the physician play a key role in obtaining a good result. Acne is
often the patient's first encounter with a chronic medical condition, and the
treatment programs are complex. Treatment failures are often related to the
patient's noncompliance, failure on the physician's part to impart instructions
clearly, or failure on the physician's part to understand the patient's social
situation and correctly assess the patient's ability to comply. Providing
concise written and oral instructions that are suited to the patient's level of
medical sophistication is essential. At follow-up evaluations, the original
therapeutic plan should be compared point by point with the steps the patient
has actually taken.
The
treatment failures not related to compliance are usually caused by five other
factors:
1.
The patient is taking medication that is exacerbating the acne or making
it resistant to treatment. The use of medications such as carbamazepine,
phenytoin, androgenic steroids, anabolic steroids, corticosteroids, and lithium
may have been overlooked in the first clinical encounter.
2.
The female patient has an underlying endocrine problem that must be
addressed. A limited endocrine and gynecologic evaluation may be appropriate.
3.
The patient has acquired gram-negative folliculitis or
antibiotic-resistant strains of P. acnes. Appropriate cultures and
antibiotic or oral retinoid treatment will be required.
4.
The diagnosis was incorrect .
5.
Treatment has not been aggressive enough.
When
acne is particularly severe and resistant to conventional treatment (see above),
the patient may benefit from treatment with isotretinoin or from hormone
manipulation.
Isotretinoin
Indications
and patient selection Treatment with isotretinoin may be considered
for patients with severe acne who have failed to respond adequately to
conventional topical and systemic therapy, patients who have relapsed soon after
several courses of oral antibiotic therapy, and patients who are
dysmorphophobic. Women of childbearing potential must meet certain additional
criteria before being given the
drug.
Proper
patient selection is essential because isotretinoin is a potent drug that
produces significant and severe side effects, especially in women. It has
substantial teratogenic potential: teratogenic effects occur in approximately 15
to 45 percent of in utero exposures. Spontaneous abortions occur in an
additional 20 to 30 percent of pregnant women. The period of greatest risk is
during the first trimester, but the risk persists for at least one month after
the drug has been discontinued. The multiple malformation syndrome that most
commonly occurs involves the face, central nervous system, and heart. In
patients who are carefully selected and monitored, however, isotretinoin has
proved to be a successful therapeutic intervention.
Additional
criteria for women who are of childbearing potential
Before isotretinoin is prescribed for a woman who can become pregnant, the
physician must determine that she is capable of understanding and carrying out
instructions and of complying with mandatory contraceptive measures. She must
then be given oral and written warnings of the hazards of taking isotretinoin
during pregnancy and exposing a fetus to the drug. She must also be given oral
and written warnings of the risk of possible contraception failure and of the
need to use two reliable forms of contraception simultaneously, unless she
abstains from sexual in tercourse or has undergone a hysterectomy. She must
acknowledge in writing her understanding of these warnings and of the need for
using two contraceptive methods. An informed consent statement appropriate for
women undergoing isotretinoin treatment is published with the package insert and
in the Physicians' Desk Reference.
Therapy
with isotretinoin should be begun on the second or third day of the next normal
menstrual period. Within one week before therapy is begun, the patient must have
negative results on a serum or urine pregnancy test with a sensitivity of at
least 50 mIU/ml.
Dosing
The normal dosage of isotretinoin is 1.0 mg/kg/day in two divided doses (an oral
dosage of 30 mg twice daily for a 60 kg patient). Up to 2.0 mg/kg/day may be
given if acne is particularly severe on the trunk or if the patient has
responded inadequately to the lower dosage. Lower starting dosages (0.5
mg/kg/day) are effective in controlling acne but are associated with
unacceptably high relapse rates when therapy is discontinued. A course of
therapy usually lasts for 20 weeks but may be shortened if an excellent response
occurs. Isotretinoin treatment is unusual in that patients often continue to
improve even after the course of therapy is completed; therefore, patients who
have an incomplete response should be followed for about eight weeks before
administration of another course of treatment is considered. About 10 to 20
percent of patients who are treated with isotretinoin at 1.0 mg/kg/day will
require a second course of treatment.
Hormone Manipulation
Few
women require endocrine and gynecologic evaluation for acne; at one acne clinic,
it was thought that hormone dysfunction accounted for acne in fewer than three
percent of the women patients. Even fewer patients are found to have polycystic
ovary disease or congenital adrenal hyperplasia as the underlying cause of their
acne. Nevertheless, selected patients do benefit from hormone manipulation.
The
finding of elevated plasma levels of dehydroepiandrosterone sulfate (DHEAS), the
principal androgen secreted by the adrenal gland, or of testosterone, the
hormone secreted in small amounts from the ovary, suggests that hormone therapy
may be of some benefit. If testosterone levels are elevated, the patient may be
treated with an oral contraceptive that contains 50 mg of estrogen. A six- to 12-month course of therapy will be
required before any benefit is seen. If DHEAS levels are elevated, the patient
may be treated with adrenal-suppressive doses of dexamethasone (0.25 to 0.5
mg/day). Improvement will occur within a few months.
Other women may have severe or resistant acne caused by so-called end-organ sensitivity. In these patients, the sebaceous glands can convert circulating androgens into the biologically much more potent dihydrotestosterone more rapidly than is normal, or the sebaceous glands are, by some means as yet undefined, hyperresponsive to androgenic stimulation. Treatment with spironolactone (150 to 200 mg/day) may be helpful in these patients.